One Imperfect Christmas: a review
February 9th, 2010
Was sent this to review.
Good cover.
Not a great start to the book… a few chapters in and I wondered if there was much point in reading on. In fact, I really wasn’t sure I could force myself to. If there isn’t a ‘desperate want or need’ in those first few pages then I find it v hard to read on. We’re presented with a perfect middle-class American christian family… which annoyed me no end. Then it transpires that grandma has had a stroke, which is a little bit interesting but not all that gripping. At this point I struggled to see what this book was really going to be about.
But it did get better… the ‘perfect’ family went to pot. I know this shouldn’t make me happy, and I hate couples splitting up and children getting hurt and all that… but at least it introduced some decent ‘conflict’ into the novel and we actually had something to get our teeth into.
Later on still I found myself slightly more interested in that the couple were a very similar age to us and had been married for just about as long AND had a daughter roughly the same age as ours! This meant I could relate to it all a bit more; it made me wonder what it would be like for us if one of our parents had a stroke and needed caring for, etc.
I was pleased to see that the ‘Christian’ bits weren’t too cringe-tastic and didn’t ruin the ‘flow’ of the book, as so often happens with christian fiction. I couldn’t say I was gripped by this book or that I’d particularly recommend it to someone, although I might if they had a parent who’d just had a stroke. I did like the way it didn’t end up too ‘happily ever after’ (in terms of both the couple getting back together and the mum with her stroke). I even shed a tear at the end when the Mum managed a little speech despite her stroke… and any book that can ‘move’ the reader has got to be given some credit, imho!
So, not that fab overall, but did make me think (re parents/strokes/marriage V career choices) due to the fact that I could relate to the protagonist, so not a total flop. A bit of humour wouldn’t have gone a miss.





My local Wetherspoons asked me to be their ‘guest local author’ at their very first Book Group! They offered free tea and coffee to all who attended and even handed round choccie biccies… yum yum!
It seems but a lifetime away, but before the memory fades altogether, being extinguished by thoughts of xmas and suchlike, just wanted to put in a couple of links:


… is the Wii Fit
On reading (on BBC news website) about Jade’s funeral, small tears appeared in my eyes. Same thing happened when I read of her death. Yes, this is freaky. What’s even more freaky is that such ‘leakage’ didn’t come as any surprise to me.






